Historical research guide · 0862 · 2002
Update on an Electromagnetic Basis for Inertia, Gravitation, the Principle of Equivalence, Spin and Particle Mass Ratios
Bernard Haisch · Alfonso Rueda · L. J. Nickisch · Jules Mollere
In one minute
Bernard Haisch, Alfonso Rueda and colleagues present this paper as a report on mass from the vacuum. In their picture a fundamental particle is a point-like charge without intrinsic mass, constantly driven by the electromagnetic zero-point field. In an accelerating frame that field is no longer symmetric: a net electromagnetic momentum flux appears, the charge scatters it and the reaction is identified as inertia. Rueda and Haisch express inertial mass as zero-point energy crossing the object and interacting with its quarks and electrons, divided by c squared. Nickisch and Mollere take a different route, letting the vacuum define curvature in a particle’s own spacetime. Their simulations produce massive-particle-like acceleration from a massless charge and associate the helical motion with spin. The authors use local Lorentz invariance to extend the proposal from inertia to weight.
Connection
Chapter 3 rests on the claim that inertia and gravity are effects of the zero-point field rather than brute facts about matter, and this is the paper where the programme’s authors gather the four strands of it in one place: the Lorentz-force derivation, the Poynting-flux derivation, the curved-spacetime version that yields the equivalence principle, and a numerical simulation in which a massless charge acquires both inertia and spin. The reason it matters beyond the physics is stated in its own opening pages — if mass is an electromagnetic effect it is in principle something you can modify, which is where chapter 8 begins.
From the source
The electromagnetic quantum vacuum has a definite spectral energy density that follows from textbook quantisation: the density of modes between two frequencies multiplied by the minimum half-Planck-constant-times-frequency of energy each mode must carry — and if the thermal term is taken to zero, that zero-point term remains.Section ‘The electromagnetic quantum vacuum (ZPF)’; Equations 1 and 2
Seen from a uniformly accelerating frame the vacuum acquires a Planck-like component at an effective temperature of h-bar times the acceleration divided by two pi times c times Boltzmann’s constant, and a full vectorial treatment adds terms beyond that quasi-thermal component; the spectral energy density stays spatially symmetric but the momentum flux does not, and that non-zero flux is the process the authors identify as underlying inertial and gravitational forces.Section ‘The electromagnetic quantum vacuum (ZPF)’; Equations 3 and 4, following Unruh, Davies and Boyer
Rueda and Haisch derive an invariant scalar with the dimensions of mass from the scattering of that momentum flux, and read it as the inertial mass: the volume of the object multiplied by the integral of an interaction coefficient against the zero-point spectral energy density, divided by the speed of light squared — so inertial mass is the amount of zero-point energy instantaneously transiting the object and interacting with its quarks and electrons, and both Newton’s second law and its relativistic form come out of the derivation.Sections ‘The Lorentz force approach to inertia (HRP)’ and ‘The Poynting vector approach to inertia (RH)’; Equations 5 and 6
Nickisch and Mollere reach inertia from the other direction, treating the electromagnetic fields including the zero-point fluctuations as a curvature in the particle’s own spacetime: a massless charge follows a null geodesic there, the geodesic is zitterbewegung, and transforming the view back to flat spacetime reproduces hyperbolic motion under a uniform electric field and uniform motion after an impulse — inertia, in simulation, out of a particle with no mass — while the helical form of the motion supplies particle spin along the lines Schroedinger proposed.Section ‘The new connectivity approach’; Equations 8 to 14; Figures 1, 2 and 3
The principle of equivalence follows immediately from local Lorentz invariance once inertia is a vacuum effect: an object accelerating through the electromagnetic quantum vacuum and an object held fixed while the vacuum accelerates past it experience the same flux, and the resulting force is called inertia in the first case and weight in the second — which is why gravitational and inertial mass are equal.Section ‘Origin of weight and the weak equivalence principle’, developing Rueda, Haisch and Tung 2001
Offered explicitly as a conjecture worthy of further study: if the effective inertial mass of a charge scales with the cube of a resonance frequency or the fourth power of an interaction cutoff, and the charge distribution can carry a lobed harmonic structure, then the heavier leptons are spatial harmonics of the electron — giving the seventh root of the muon-to-electron mass ratio as 2.1 and of the tau-to-electron ratio as 3.2 for a cutoff, or sixth roots of 2.4 and 3.9 for a resonance, close enough to whole numbers that form factors could account for the rest.Section ‘The new connectivity approach’, closing paragraphs; Figure 4
The way in
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0209016How to cite it
Bernard Haisch, Alfonso Rueda, L. J. Nickisch, Jules Mollere (2002) Update on an Electromagnetic Basis for Inertia, Gravitation, the Principle of Equivalence, Spin and Particle Mass Ratios doi:10.1063/1.1541386