Historical research guide · 0809 · 2015
The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics
Luis de la Peña · Ana María Cetto · Andrea Valdés-Hernández
In one minute
This is the book-length statement of a programme three physicists at Mexico’s national university have run for half a century. Luis de la Peña, Ana María Cetto and Andrea Valdés-Hernández argue that quantum mechanics works beautifully but explains nothing, because a real physical ingredient was left out when the theory was built — the random zero-point electromagnetic field that Planck put into physics in 1912. Put it back, they say, and the theory stops being a rulebook and becomes a mechanism. Their ten chapters do it in order: first the questions the standard account cannot answer, then the blackbody spectrum shown to be a forced consequence of the fluctuating field, then two long derivations that arrive at Schrödinger’s equation and at Heisenberg’s matrices from the same starting point — a charged particle in permanent contact with the field. Later chapters take on the Lamb shift, entanglement, and the wave nature of matter. The closing chapter returns to the opening questions with answers.
Connection
Chapter 2 argues that the vacuum is a real structured medium rather than an absence, and this book is that argument made at the foundations of quantum theory itself, by authors who have carried it further than anyone. Chapter 3 borrows its central mechanism — a particle held in balance against the zero-point field — which is the balance Puthoff carried forward into inertia and gravity, and chapter 13 needs its conclusion: one world, with the quantum arising inside it rather than replacing it.
From the source
The book’s governing thesis is that quantum mechanics is incomplete in a physical rather than a mathematical sense, and that the missing ingredient must be electromagnetic rather than mechanical, because atomic stability and atomic transitions are electromagnetic processes. The candidate the authors name is the random zero-point radiation field introduced by Planck in 1912.Chapter 1, Quantum Mechanics: Some Questions, pages 1 to 31; the same thesis restated by the authors in arXiv 2210.16388v1, section 3
The Planck distribution is not an input to the theory but an output of it. The authors show that the blackbody spectrum, including its zero-point term of one half h-bar omega per mode, is a necessary consequence of a fluctuating zero-point field in equilibrium with matter.Chapter 3, The Planck Distribution, a Necessary Consequence of the Fluctuating Zero-Point Field, pages 67 to 93
One starting point yields both formulations of quantum mechanics. Taking an otherwise classical charged particle in permanent contact with the zero-point field, and following a statistical treatment, the authors reach the Schrödinger equation in one long derivation and Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics in another, under what they call non-essential restrictions.Chapter 4, The Long Journey to the Schrödinger Equation, pages 95 to 149, and Chapter 5, The Road to Heisenberg Quantum Mechanics, pages 151 to 193; attested by the authors in arXiv 2210.16388v1, section 4.1
The framework reaches past the Schrödinger equation into territory normally reserved for quantum electrodynamics: the radiative corrections, including the Lamb shift and the Einstein coefficient for spontaneous emission, are derived without quantum field theory, from the same particle-and-field balance.Chapter 6, Beyond the Schrödinger Equation, pages 195 to 235, cited for the Lamb shift by the authors themselves in arXiv 2210.16388v1
Entanglement is given a physical carrier. Because two particles that never interact directly are nevertheless both in contact with the same background field modes, the field induces correlations between their motions — which is what the authors offer in place of an unexplained nonlocality, alongside a full treatment of causality and the Bell analysis.Chapter 7, Disentangling Quantum Entanglement, pages 237 to 265, and Chapter 8, Causality, Nonlocality, and Entanglement in Quantum Mechanics, pages 267 to 307
The wave nature of matter is treated as an effect of the field acting on the particle rather than a primitive fact about the particle, and the field’s permanent action is what fixes the stationary states — the accelerated electron radiates, absorbs from the field, and only certain motions balance the two exactly.Chapter 9, The Zero-Point Field Waves (and) Matter, pages 309 to 330, closing in Chapter 10, Quantum Mechanics: Some Answers, pages 331 to 345
The way in
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-07893-9How to cite it
Luis de la Peña, Ana María Cetto, Andrea Valdés-Hernández (2015) The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics doi:10.1007/978-3-319-07893-9