The Spacetime Metric

Ages 8–12 · about 6 minutes

Fusion Inside a Block of Metal

Could you run the Sun's own reaction inside a lump of metal?

The big idea

Metal is not solid to the smallest things, and things can happen in the gaps.

fusion
When two tiny nuclei join into one and let out a burst of energy.
lattice
The neat repeating grid that atoms sit in inside a metal.
screening
When electrons crowd in between and soften the shove between two nuclei.

Could you run the Sun's own reaction inside a lump of metal?

Deep inside the Sun, tiny nuclei crash together and stick. That joining is called fusion, and it is where sunlight comes from. It normally takes millions of degrees.

Nuclei hate joining. They all carry the same electric charge, so they shove each other away hard. It is like trying to push together two magnets that refuse. Metal, though, turns out to be a very interesting place to try.

A dark blue slab of metal with several slender columns of violet light passing straight through it.
Columns of light running straight through a solid slab of metal. To the very smallest things, metal is not solid at all. Its atoms sit in a grid, and there is room in between.

What we know for sure

Two pieces of ordinary textbook physics do the work here.

The first is called screening. Load a metal grid with heavy hydrogen and something helpful happens. The metal is swimming with loose electrons. Those electrons crowd in between the nuclei and partly cancel the shove.

The second was worked out in 1935 by Robert Oppenheimer and Melba Phillips. Heavy hydrogen can react with a nucleus at lower energy than ordinary hydrogen needs.

In 2020 scientists at NASA Glenn published two papers about this. They appeared in Physical Review C, a serious mainstream nuclear physics journal. The team included Pines, Steinetz, Benyo and Forsley.

They packed erbium and titanium with heavy hydrogen. Then they fired high-energy gamma rays at the metal. They measured new nuclear products coming out, including neutrons.

What scientists are testing right now

Now read that result carefully, because the careful reading is the whole lesson. NASA measured reactions. NASA did not measure net energy. Those are two different things.

Energy went into the metal as gamma rays. Nothing came out of nowhere. The claim is narrow, and that is what makes it strong.

This matters because of 1989. Two scientists announced tabletop fusion then, and other laboratories could not repeat it. A careful re-test published in 2019 found no extra heat at those old levels. But it did point at screening physics as worth studying. That is the very thing NASA went on to build.

Companies are chasing it now. Clean Planet in Japan works with Tohoku University. Astral Systems is newer. Both report extra heat from loaded metal.

The next milestone is clear. Another laboratory must see the same products under the same beam. Then somebody must measure the heat and show the books balance.

Why it matters

Every idea in this book needs the same thing first. A small source of enormous energy.

Picture a block of metal giving out steady power. No smoke, no fuel truck, no wires from the horizon. That would change how everyone on Earth lives.

Your turn

Why does it matter so much that the energy went in as gamma rays? And how would you weigh the heat coming out of a lump of metal?

Nobody has closed the energy books yet. That measurement is waiting. Perhaps you will make it.

Try this at home

The jar that was already full

You need: A clear jar, a handful of marbles or dried peas all the same size, and some rice

  1. 1.Fill the jar with marbles until you truly cannot squeeze another one in.
  2. 2.Hold it up to the light and look carefully at the gaps between them.
  3. 3.Now pour rice in slowly, shaking the jar gently as you go.

Notice: The jar was full, and an astonishing amount of rice still went in. A metal is like that. Its atoms sit in a neat grid with room in between, and that is exactly where scientists hide hydrogen when they want fusion in a solid.

For grown-ups and older readers

This lesson comes from Chapter 12: Lattice Confinement Fusion and the map unit Lattice confinement fusion.